Some interesting points, most of which I don't agree with.
As for the 37% figure I used, the totals you provided confirm it:- add all three of your categories together and you get a total electorate of 46,555,001. The leave vote represents 37% of that figure.
That aside, I'm sure you realise that I was merely calling out the willfull deceit of another correspondent and to show that you must treat all statistics with a great deal of care.
On the matter of compulsory voting I am not sure I follow the logic of your argument. On the one hand you seem to be saying people who don't vote are bone idle and because they don't vote should have no say. Yet on the other you are demanding the right to abstain / not to vote. There seems to me to be a fundamental contradiction there. Surely you cannot, on the one hand, condem people for not voting yet at the same time demand that they have the right to do so. Are you, in effect, demanding the right for people to be bone idle? It seems so. Perhaps I am missing something in your argument. I realise both standpoints are not mutually exclusive but to hold both so vehemently seems a bit inconsistent.
I am also concerned that you have chosen not to comment on the many and varied reasons why people chose not to vote. You don't have to look very far to discover reasons why great swathes of the population feel disenfranchised. People all over these islands have been marginalised to the extent that they feel their voice doesn't count. No-one listens to them anyway, so why vote? Another reason for people not voting is that trust in politicians is at an all time low. Many take the view that politicians lie to get into power and lie to stay there once elected. Promises are never kept so why take part in the charade?
I do see many merits in compulsory voting. Too many people suffered (and even died) to ensure the universal adult suffrage we now enjoy. It seems to me a betrayal of their efforts not to vote. Even if you just spoil your ballot paper or choose the "none of the above" option, if available, that means you have partaken. Democracy is fragile and we must do all we can to protect it.
On the matter of membership of political unions the issue is simple for me. For all its many faults the EU is much more a union of equals than the UK has ever been or will be. Look at the Brexit negotiations. Tiny countries like Malta and Cyprus had more of a say over Scotland's future than we did. They had a veto to use if they didn't like the direction of the negotiations. All Scotland got was being ignored by a Westminster government who paid no heed whatsoever to the overwhelming wishes of the Scottish electorate. Scotland had/has no veto. We just had to fall in line and do what we were told. Ireland was protected and supported by the EU during the negotiations. Not Scotland though - back in your box and shut up. Scotland is supposed to be an equal and valued member of the UK. Aye, right!
You say you support a "clean break Brexit", By that I assume you mean a "no deal Brexit". Even if you are right (which I don't think you are) and the UK's ability to do trade deals would be feared it could take years, perhaps decades, to put in place. In the intervening period we will be subject to huge disruption to our usual trading arrangements not least of which will be tariffs and the likelihood of shortages in essential supplies. Supply chains have been carefully established and adapted over the period of our EU membership. They cannot be replaced with new working arrangements at 00.01 hours on 1 February without there being huge logistical problems. Not being able to buy a German car will be the least of our problems. (Oh, and as for the UK being the world's biggest market for Mercedes; is that as a percentage of the total number of Mercedes sold worldwide; absolute number of cars imported to the UK compared to other countries; or is it the absolute total value of sales to the UK or just the percentage? You see the problems with stat's.).
Finally, it looks like you may be a Jim Hacker fan. At least that is something we can agree on.
Bookmarks