PDA

View Full Version : Another reason why having too many legal and humanities people in government is bad



RecQuery
28-Jun-11, 09:38
[/URL][URL="http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jun/24/bad-science-local-goverment-savings-ben-goldacre"] http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jun/24/bad-science-local-goverment-savings-ben-goldacre (http://%20http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jun/24/bad-science-local-goverment-savings-ben-goldacre)

Basically Ben Goldacre utterly destroys the credibility of the government's £10bn efficiency savings report.

This is genuinely astounding. The report extrapolates possible 20% savings on mobile phone bills, which cost £600,000, to the entire local government budget of £50bn, and concludes that £10bn savings are possible. This figure is then used to demonstrate that budget cuts need not affect frontline services. Eric Pickles response, from his departmental press release:


Let there be no doubt whatsoever - today's figures show that there is significant scope for councils to make taxpayers' money work even harder. We've always said that sunlight is the best disinfectant, and the availability of financial data has helped identify numerous ways that councils can reduce expenditure while offering the same or better services to residents. If councils improved their procurement and joint working on waste services, councils could afford to offer more frequent and regular rubbish collections. There's no excuse for cutting the front line when there are so many savings to be found in the way back office services and run and paid for.

Beyond belief and another reason we need more scientists and engineers in government.

EDIT: Fixing link

NickInTheNorth
28-Jun-11, 10:26
The link in your post won't work for me, there an extra http and space in the link so hope this one will work :

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jun/24/bad-science-local-goverment-savings-ben-goldacre

It is a truly astonishingly bad piece of research and advice!! No wonder the government are insisting, against all logic that the cuts can be made without impacting front line services. With this quality of work I reckon I can probably cut my household expenditure by £2.4 billion over the next 18 months :)

RecQuery
28-Jun-11, 10:36
The link in your post won't work for me, there an extra http and space in the link so hope this one will work :

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jun/24/bad-science-local-goverment-savings-ben-goldacre

It is a truly astonishingly bad piece of research and advice!! No wonder the government are insisting, against all logic that the cuts can be made without impacting front line services. With this quality of work I reckon I can probably cut my household expenditure by £2.4 billion over the next 18 months :)

Cheers, fixed. Problem with that another JavaScript WYSIWYG editor.

It's not as bad as some government interpretations of dodgy research I suppose, still pretty bad though.

ducati
28-Jun-11, 10:37
Chucking out the current procurement system in it's entirety would save billions. the trouble is, the people who designed it, Engineers and Scientists, sold it to them on the basis it would save billions.:roll: